Picksights
Controllers · PS5 & Xbox

Best Controller for PS5 and Xbox Series X

A controller is locked to its console — a PS5 pad can't be used natively on Xbox Series X/S and GTA VI has no PC version at launch. So this isn't one ranking: it's two, one per platform, each ranked on its own terms.

Updated 2026-07-291 min read
Setting up for GTA VI? This ranking is part of our GTA VI setup collection — every guide we’ve published for the launch, in one place.

Picksights may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. This never affects which products we rank higher — our Picksights Score is calculated from published specs before any affiliate relationship is considered. See our ranking methodology below.

As an Amazon Associate, Picksights earns from qualifying purchases.

PlayStation 5

Ranked by Picksights Score. Prices are approximate and change frequently.
ProductPicksights ScoreFromBest for
#1 · Turtle Beach Turtle Beach Victrix Pro BFG Reloaded7.7/10$209.99Best for customization
#2 · Nacon Nacon Revolution 5 Pro6.8/10$199.99Best wireless latency
#3 · Sony Sony DualSense Edge6.7/10$199.99Best premium
#4 · Sony Sony DualSense6.1/10$69.99Best budget / default

Swipe the table sideways to see every column.

Top pick

Turtle Beach Turtle Beach Victrix Pro BFG Reloaded
PS7.7/10

Best for customization

This is the pad that beats Sony at its own customization game, and it is worth being specific about how. The DualSense Edge gives you two back buttons and swappable stick modules; this gives you eleven interchangeable components, four mappable buttons and a six-button fightpad module, and its sticks and triggers are Hall-effect — magnetic sensing that does not wear the way potentiometer sticks do, which is the failure that eventually kills most pro controllers. It also lasts around four times longer per charge. What you give up is precisely what makes a DualSense feel like a DualSense. Haptic feedback and adaptive triggers are Sony's own technology and no third-party pad has them, so a game built around trigger resistance loses that layer entirely. There is no Bluetooth either, and reviewers consistently note rattle in the fightpad buttons. So it is the best buy here for a competitive player who wants a pad tuned to their hands and expects it to outlast the warranty — and the wrong buy for someone who plays single-player games for the immersion.

Pros

  • 11 interchangeable components plus a 6-button fightpad module with Kailh microswitches
  • Hall-effect sticks and triggers — the drift-resistant technology the DualSense Edge lacks
  • Up to 20 hours per charge, by far the longest in this comparison

Cons

  • No haptic feedback or adaptive triggers — those remain Sony proprietary technology
  • No Bluetooth connectivity
  • Reviewers report rattle in the fightpad module buttons

From $209.99Approximate — prices change

See current price(opens in a new tab)

Sources: Notebookcheck review (2025) · PlayStation Direct (2026)Last checked by Picksights 2026-07-29

Nacon

Number 2: Nacon Revolution 5 Pro

PS6.8/10

Best wireless latency

The competitive-play option: reviewers measured some of the lowest latency of any pad in this class, and the battery roughly doubles the Edge. The trade-offs are the dongle, the membrane D-pad that several reviewers dislike, and the same missing Sony features every third-party pad lacks.

Pros

  • Hall-effect sticks and triggers, with swappable sticks, D-pads and internal weights
  • Around 10 hours per charge — roughly double the DualSense Edge
  • Deep software customization app plus a hard carrying case in the box

Cons

  • Wireless play requires a USB dongle rather than connecting directly to the console
  • Cannot power the PS5 on — a limitation Sony imposes on third-party pads
  • No haptic feedback or adaptive triggers in PS5 mode

From $199.99Approximate — prices change

See current price(opens in a new tab)

Sources: GamesRadar+ review (2023-12-19) · Trusted Reviews (2024-05-09)Last checked by Picksights 2026-07-29

Sony Sony DualSense Edge

Sony

Number 3: Sony DualSense Edge

PS6.7/10

Best premium

The customization is real and the haptics are still the best in the business, but the battery life is a genuine step down from the already-mediocre standard DualSense. Worth it specifically for players who want stick-drift insurance and back paddles — not a clear across-the-board upgrade.

Pros

  • Swappable stick modules — replace worn sticks instead of the whole pad
  • Back paddles and full button remapping with saved profiles
  • Same industry-leading haptics and adaptive triggers as the standard DualSense

Cons

  • Weakest battery life in this comparison (~5-6 hours per charge)
  • Almost 3x the price of a standard DualSense
  • Only 2 back buttons vs 4 on Xbox's Elite Series 2

From $199.99Approximate — prices change

See current price(opens in a new tab)

Sources: TechRadar (2026-04-25) · TechRadar (2023-01-23) · Tom's Guide review (2023)Last checked by Picksights 2026-07-28

Sony Sony DualSense

Sony

Number 4: Sony DualSense

PS6.1/10

Best budget / default

For most players, this is genuinely all you need — the Edge's extra customization is a real but narrow upgrade, not a different gaming experience. Buy a second one of these before considering the Edge.

Pros

  • Same haptic feedback and adaptive triggers as the $200 Edge model
  • $69.99 — the complete, no-compromises way to play GTA VI on PS5 as designed
  • No accessory learning curve — it's the controller the console was designed around

Cons

  • No swappable sticks, back paddles, or saved profiles
  • Battery life (4-8 hours) is still mediocre — just not worse than the Edge

From $69.99Approximate — prices change

See current price(opens in a new tab)

Sources: TechRadar (2026-04-25)Last checked by Picksights 2026-07-29

Xbox Series X/S

Ranked by Picksights Score. Prices are approximate and change frequently.
ProductPicksights ScoreFromBest for
#1 · Microsoft Xbox Elite Wireless Controller Series 28.2/10$179.99Best premium
#2 · Microsoft Xbox Elite Wireless Controller Series 2 Core8.1/10$129.99Best value pro controller
#3 · Turtle Beach Turtle Beach Victrix Pro BFG Reloaded (Xbox)7.8/10$209.99Best for customization
#4 · Microsoft Xbox Wireless Controller6.5/10$59.99Best budget

Swipe the table sideways to see every column.

Top pick

Microsoft Xbox Elite Wireless Controller Series 2

Microsoft

Number 1: Xbox Elite Wireless Controller Series 2

PS8.2/10

Best premium

Wins clearly on customization and battery life against Sony's equivalent, at $20 less. If you're committed to Xbox Series X for GTA VI and want a pro pad, this is the one to get.

Pros

  • Up to 40 hours of battery life — far ahead of Sony's pro controller
  • 4 swappable back paddles included (Sony's Edge ships with 2)
  • Adjustable-tension thumbsticks and short hair-trigger locks

Cons

  • $179.99 MSRP
  • Noticeably heavier than the standard Xbox controller — not everyone prefers that

From $179.99Approximate — prices change

See current price(opens in a new tab)

Sources: TechRadar (2026-04-25)Last checked by Picksights 2026-07-28

Microsoft Xbox Elite Wireless Controller Series 2 Core

Microsoft

Number 2: Xbox Elite Wireless Controller Series 2 Core

PS8.1/10

Best value pro controller

By our weighting this comes within half a point of the full Elite Series 2 — you're giving up included accessories, not the two specs (battery, adjustable sticks) that matter most day to day.

Pros

  • Same 40-hour battery and adjustable-tension sticks as the full Elite Series 2
  • $50 cheaper than the full Elite Series 2 at MSRP
  • Back paddles, case and extra sticks can be added later if you want them

Cons

  • Ships without the carrying case, extra sticks or back paddles of the full version

From $129.99Approximate — prices change

See current price(opens in a new tab)

Sources: TechRadar (2026-04-25)Last checked by Picksights 2026-07-29

Turtle Beach Turtle Beach Victrix Pro BFG Reloaded (Xbox)
PS7.8/10

Best for customization

Until this arrived, every controller in this ranking was made by Microsoft — which meant the ranking was really a comparison of one company's product tiers. The Victrix brings genuine competition: more modularity than the Elite Series 2 and Hall-effect sticks, which matter because stick drift is what kills pro controllers. You pay more and lose Bluetooth for it.

Pros

  • The only non-Microsoft option here — officially licensed for Xbox Series X|S
  • Hall-effect sticks and triggers, the drift-resistant technology the Elite Series 2 lacks
  • Up to 20 hours per charge, against the Elite Series 2's rated 40 on paper but far less in practice for most owners

Cons

  • More expensive than the Elite Series 2 it competes with
  • No Bluetooth connectivity
  • Reviewers report rattle in the fightpad module buttons

From $209.99Approximate — prices change

See current price(opens in a new tab)

Sources: Notebookcheck review (2025) · GameSpot (2025-11-10)Last checked by Picksights 2026-07-29

Microsoft Xbox Wireless Controller

Microsoft

Number 4: Xbox Wireless Controller

PS6.5/10

Best budget

If you don't already know you want pro-controller features, you don't need them for GTA VI. This is the complete, well-built default — the Elite tier is for players who've specifically identified a need for paddles or tension tuning.

Pros

  • $59.99 — the cheapest way to play GTA VI on Xbox Series X/S
  • AA batteries mean you're never stuck waiting on a recharge
  • The controller the console ships with — zero learning curve

Cons

  • No remapping, paddles, or tension adjustment without buying accessories separately

From $59.99Approximate — prices change

See current price(opens in a new tab)

Sources: TechRadar (2026-04-25)Last checked by Picksights 2026-07-29

How we rank

Picksights methodology

Picksights Score is a weighted average of 4 criteria, applied separately within each platform (a PS5 controller is never scored against an Xbox one):

Customization (remapping, swappable sticks, back paddles)

30% of score

Build quality

25% of score

Battery life

20% of score

Price-to-value within this comparison

15% of score

FAQ

Can I use a PS5 controller on Xbox Series X, or vice versa, for GTA VI?

No. GTA VI has no PC version at launch, and PS5/Xbox controllers use different wireless protocols that aren't cross-compatible with the other console natively. Buy the controller for the console you actually own.

Do I need a pro controller (DualSense Edge or Elite Series 2) to play GTA VI well?

No. The standard controller that ships with your console is a complete, fully-capable way to play GTA VI. Pro controllers add remapping, back paddles and (on Xbox) longer battery life — genuinely useful for some players, but not a requirement for the game itself.

Related guides and comparisons

Also worth a look